The State Audit Office of Vietnam (SAV) has recently published the results of a thematic audit on the management and use of public investment capital in Khanh Hoa Province during the 2021–2025 period. The audit revealed that 53 projects had to be suspended after their investment policies were approved; one project had achieved a disbursement rate of only 18.76% as of the audit date; and another project, scheduled for completion and handover in 2026, had only begun its investment preparation procedures by July 2026, when the audit was conducted.

During 2021–2025, Khanh Hoa Province concentrated public investment resources on infrastructure development. Illustrative photo. Source: ST.
53 Projects Suspended After Investment Policy Approval
According to SAV, during the 2021–2025 period, Khanh Hoa Province concentrated public investment resources on transport infrastructure, irrigation, urban improvement, agriculture, healthcare, education, and climate change adaptation. These investments gradually translated approved development plans into practice, strengthened regional connectivity, improved living conditions, and created momentum for local socio-economic development.
Overall, the management and administration of medium-term public investment plans received considerable attention and direction from People's Councils and People's Committees at various levels. Capital allocation and adjustments were made based on budgetary capacity and local practical requirements. Project formulation, appraisal, approval, contractor selection, quality management, acceptance, payment, and final settlement were generally carried out in accordance with the Law on Public Investment, the Law on Construction, the Law on Bidding, and relevant implementing regulations.
However, the audit identified several significant shortcomings in the management and use of public investment capital that require corrective action.
The public investment disbursement rate during 2021–2025 reached 88.5%, falling short of the 90% target stipulated in Point c, Clause 2, Article 1 of National Assembly Resolution No. 29/2021/QH15 dated July 28, 2021.
By the end of the 2025 fiscal year, several projects had failed to disburse their allocated capital on schedule, requiring extensions of implementation and disbursement periods into 2026. Capital allocations that were ineligible for carryover had to be cancelled.
The province had not returned VND 2.641 billion to the central budget after the prescribed implementation and disbursement periods had expired under Clause 2, Article 72 of the 2024 Law on Public Investment No. 58/2024/QH15. This was inconsistent with Clause 2, Article 9 of Ministry of Finance Circular No. 26/2026/TT-BTC dated March 25, 2026.
Notably, 53 projects were suspended after their investment policies had been approved. Of these, 33 projects had not yet received capital allocations, while 20 projects had been allocated a total of VND 33.313 billion.
In addition, five provincially managed projects were delayed in preparing their final settlement reports. As of the audit date, three projects had submitted their settlement dossiers.
The Khanh Hoa Provincial People's Committee authorized the Director of the Department of Finance to approve final settlements for Group C projects under Decision No. 2475/QD-UBND dated December 13, 2025. However, Article 2 of this Decision did not specify the authorization period, as required under Point a, Clause 2, Article 14 of the 2025 Law on Organization of Local Government.

Project cost estimates contained duplicated and excessive quantities compared with design documents
The audit also revealed that the approved alignment of the Dien Khanh District Interregional Road Construction Project intersected with the planned high-speed railway alignment. However, the project had not obtained comments from the Ministry of Transport (before its merger) regarding the high-speed railway alignment.
For Component Project 1 of the Dien Khanh District Interregional Road Construction Project, the survey of earth-fill material sources relied solely on the total reserves of material quarries without adequately assessing their permitted annual extraction capacities.
At the audited project owners and Project Management Boards (PMBs), cost estimates included duplicated and excessive quantities compared with the design documents. Notably, for the Project to Construct the Headquarters of the Khanh Hoa Provincial Party Committee, the National Assembly Delegation, the People's Council and the Provincial People's Committee, several material unit prices were not included in the price announcements issued by the Department of Construction. Nevertheless, the design consultant had not collected quotations at the construction location. Furthermore, the prices of certain materials and supplies were determined inconsistently with suppliers' quotations, while quantities for several work items were incorrectly calculated in the cost estimates.
For the Domestic Water Supply System Project for the Northern Communes, the project owner signed a contract appendix extending the implementation period of a bidding package before the competent authority had approved an adjustment to the project schedule. This was inconsistent with Clause 3, Article 39 of Government Decree No. 37/2015/ND-CP dated April 22, 2015, on construction contracts.
For the Le Quy Don High School for the Gifted Project (Phase 2), the project owner signed a contract for construction and installation of fire prevention and firefighting equipment with an implementation period of 240 days starting in August 2024, extending beyond the project schedule approved by the competent authority.
The bidding documents for construction packages under the projects (Dien Lac Primary School Project; D1 Road Project (from Provincial Road 2 to National Highway 27C); Dien Khanh District Interregional Road Construction Project) did not specify advance payment rates or the number of construction contract advance payments, as required under Clause 3, Article 18 of Decree No. 37/2015/ND-CP.
Several project owners failed to fully publish contractor selection results for packages awarded through simplified direct appointment procedures on the National E-Procurement System and the Bidding Newspaper, contrary to Clause 1, Article 8 of the Law on Bidding (Northern Ring Road Project of Ninh Thuan Province (section from Khanh Nhon Pass to National Highway 1); Project to Complete the Secondary Pipeline Canal and Tertiary Canal System under the Song Cai–Tan My Irrigation System; Component Project 2: Section from National Highway 1 to Ca Na General Seaport under the Road Connection Project Linking the North–South Expressway, National Highway 1 and Ca Na General Seaport; Ong Cao Stream Embankment Project in Cam Phuoc Dong Commune, Cam Ranh City; Project to Renovate and Upgrade the Flood Drainage Systems of Suoi Hanh and Ta Ruc Reservoirs).

Site clearance activities remained slow and failed to meet project implementation schedules. Collected photo.
Disbursement rates below requirements and delays in several projects
According to SAV, at the Khanh Hoa Provincial Development Project Management Board, the 2025 capital allocation plan did not prioritize sufficient funding for projects (the Headquarters Construction Project for the Provincial Party Committee, National Assembly Delegation, People's Council and Provincial People's Committee, with a funding shortfall of VND 15.74 billion; and the Le Quy Don High School for the Gifted Project, with a shortfall of VND 1.397 billion) scheduled for completion in 2025 under the approved implementation schedules. Although these projects were completed and handed over for use in 2025, no capital allocation had been made in the 2026 plan to pay for completed work, as required under Clause 4, Article 54 of the 2024 Law on Public Investment.
At the Khanh Hoa Provincial Project Management Board for Agricultural and Transport Construction Investments, Component Project 1 of the Dien Khanh District Interregional Road Construction Project failed to meet the minimum required disbursement rate of 95%. As of the audit date, the project had disbursed only 18.76% of its allocated capital, equivalent to VND 65.687 billion out of VND 350 billion. Without decisive measures to resolve site clearance difficulties, the project risked failing to meet the disbursement target directed by the Prime Minister.
For the Headquarters Construction Project for the Khanh Hoa Provincial Party Committee, National Assembly Delegation, People's Council and Provincial People's Committee, the as-built documentation for the third-floor rooftop landscaping works was inconsistent with the construction quality records, including the construction diary. This provided an insufficient basis for preparing the facility maintenance documentation as required. Acceptance records for exposed electrical cables and connection accessories under the solar energy system also differed from the design calculations and the design documents governing the selection of electrical wires and cables.
Site clearance remained slow and failed to meet project implementation schedules as required under Clause 2, Article 108 of the 2014 Law on Construction. Consequently, several projects required adjustments and extensions to their implementation periods.
Some audited projects remained behind their original approved schedules despite having received extensions and had not yet been completed (Project to Replace Three Bridges: Thac Ngua, Song Giang and Song Cho on Provincial Road 8B in Khanh Vinh District, Khanh Hoa Province, delayed by 7.5 months; Le Duan Road Project, Section 3 (from Nguyen Luong Bang Street to Le Loi Street (C1 Road)), delayed by seven months with two schedule extensions; Domestic Water Supply System Project for the Northern Communes of Khanh Binh, Khanh Dong and Khanh Hiep, delayed by eight months). Meanwhile, Component Project 1 of the Dien Khanh District Interregional Road Construction Project had achieved a disbursement rate of only 18.76% under its 2026 capital plan, equivalent to VND 65.687 billion out of VND 350 billion.
For the Le Quy Don High School for the Gifted Project (Phase 2), unpaid completed work under Bidding Package No. 18 amounted to VND 1.035 billion as of the audit date.
The D6 Bridge Construction Project was scheduled for completion and handover in 2026, with the objective of providing a foundation for completing the technical infrastructure of the residential area north of To Hap Town. However, as of July 2026, the locality had only begun investment preparation procedures for the connecting roads, namely Dinh Tien Hoang Road and N3 Road, in accordance with the planning approved by the competent authority and Official Letter No. 9042/UBND-KT dated July 15, 2026, issued by the Khanh Hoa Provincial People's Committee. This situation posed a risk of reducing the project's investment efficiency after the D6 Bridge was handed over for use if the connecting roads had not yet been completed.
Recommendations for financial adjustments and corrective measures for relevant organizations and individuals
Following the audit, SAV recommended financial adjustments totaling VND 6.811 billion (including recovery of VND 1.175 billion in expenditures made contrary to regulations for remittance to the state budget; recovery of VND 2.641 billion in surplus funds; and reduction of VND 2.995 billion in the value of acceptance and payments for capital construction works and projects), along with other financial recommendations totaling VND 751.7 million.
At the same time, SAV recommended that the Khanh Hoa Provincial People's Committee:
Assess the causes of shortcomings, draw lessons from implementation and strengthen its direction, capital allocation and capital reallocation measures to ensure that public investment disbursement rates meet the targets assigned by the National Assembly under Resolution No. 29/2021/QH15 in subsequent planning periods;
Direct the Department of Finance to advise on capital allocation in accordance with legal regulations to settle payments for completed work (Le Quy Don High School for the Gifted Project (Phase 2)); accelerate the full disbursement of VND 1,656.8 billion in capital carried forward to 2026; and promptly review the 53 suspended projects following local administrative restructuring to prevent losses and waste in investment and construction activities.
Direct relevant units to coordinate the preparation of final settlement reports for completed projects (Ninh Thuan Vocational College – Ninh Thuan Vocational Secondary School Project; Border Guard Command – Project to Construct a New Provincial Weapons and Ammunition Warehouse and Renovate and Upgrade the Barracks of Company 19); and require the agencies responsible for examining settlement dossiers to accelerate the approval of final settlements for the three projects that had already submitted their dossiers, in accordance with Government Decree No. 254/2025/ND-CP dated September 26, 2025.
Direct relevant organizations and individuals to review and rectify shortcomings in registering capital requirements and allocating insufficient capital to projects scheduled for completion in 2025 under their approved investment decisions.
Direct relevant individuals to review and rectify shortcomings in appraising and approving cost estimates containing duplicated or excessive quantities compared with design drawings; appraising project investment policies inconsistent with the general urban development plan of Dien Khanh District through 2030; submitting feasibility study reports for appraisal before submitting environmental impact assessment reports to competent state authorities for appraisal; and organizing contractor selection and signing contracts involving performance guarantees and extensions of performance guarantees that did not comply with regulations.
Rectify shortcomings and draw lessons from delays in approving adjustments to project implementation periods and the failure to consult the former Ministry of Transport on the planned high-speed railway alignment.
Direct project owners and units responsible for compensation, support and resettlement to implement solutions to accelerate site clearance and ensure timely handover of land for construction; ensure adequate earth-fill material supplies in line with project requirements and schedules; accelerate construction progress and complete projects in accordance with their investment objectives, thereby improving the efficiency of state budget capital utilization and preventing investment waste; and coordinate with relevant authorities to seek the Ministry of Construction's opinion on proposed intersections with the planned high-speed railway alignment, ensuring compliance with applicable laws.
Direct the Department of Finance and relevant agencies to review and amend Article 2 of Decision No. 2475/QD-UBND dated December 13, 2025, to specify the authorization period granted to the Director of the Department of Finance, in accordance with Point a, Clause 2, Article 14 of the 2025 Law on Organization of Local Government.
SAV recommended that the Khanh Hoa Provincial Department of Finance rectify shortcomings and draw lessons from the consolidation and preparation of annual state budget expenditure settlement reports to ensure compliance with prescribed reporting templates in subsequent years; and return VND 2.641 billion to the central budget, representing funds for which the implementation and disbursement periods had expired and the expenditure purposes were no longer valid, in accordance with regulations.
For project owners, PMBs and relevant units, SAV required corrective measures and lessons to be drawn from errors and shortcomings in project management. Specifically:
Khanh Son Commune People's Committee should coordinate with relevant departments and agencies to urgently implement the road connecting to the D6 Bridge Construction Project (Kim Dong–Lac Long Quan Intersection), in accordance with Official Letter No. 9042/UBND-KT dated July 15, 2026, issued by the Khanh Hoa Provincial People's Committee, to ensure synchronized infrastructure connectivity and prevent waste of investment capital. The Committee should also focus on measures to accelerate construction progress and complete projects, ensuring that investment objectives are achieved and state budget capital is used efficiently.
Dien Lac Commune People's Committee should require the contractor implementing the D1 Road Project (from Provincial Road 2 to National Highway 27C) to extend its contract performance guarantee in accordance with applicable regulations.
The Khanh Hoa Provincial Project Management Board for Agricultural and Transport Construction Investments should coordinate with relevant units to strictly manage the determination of construction quantities, acceptance and payment based on actual work performed, particularly the quantities of bored piles for bridge abutments and piers, the height of settlement-prevention earth fills and surcharge fills used for settlement treatment. For projects delayed beyond their originally approved schedules, project owners should concentrate on measures to accelerate construction and ensure timely completion, thereby achieving investment objectives and improving the efficiency of state budget capital utilization.
The Khanh Hoa Provincial Development Project Management Board should coordinate with relevant units to implement the following measures: Revise the as-built drawings for the third-floor rooftop landscaping works to accurately reflect actual construction conditions, providing a proper basis for preparing facility maintenance documentation; inspect and review the quality and specifications of electrical cables and connection accessories under the solar energy system to ensure consistency with actual construction conditions and electrical safety during system operation; and inspect, review and determine whether the excavated Class II soil from the underground water tank excavation (excluding soil used for backfilling the tank) meets the quality requirements for reuse as site-leveling fill, providing a basis for acceptance and payment for the transportation and disposal of excavated soil.